fairplaythings.com

March 17, 2011

When commentaries get too long - a roboplastic rebuttal

Filed under: Uncategorized — fairplaythings @ 4:35 pm

I am now a victim of the Roboplastic Podcastalypse.

Since getting my first (classic 160 gig) iPod over the Christmas holidays, I have diligently placed 600 CDs onto this shiny piece of McShiny to take with me on the road. Then I discovered podcasts, and currently listen to little more than the ongoing opinions of Mr. Dan Savage. But there are toy(pod)casts out there and I am beginning to seek them out (and if you have recommendations, please leave them in a comment for me.) Which brings me back to the Roboplastic Apocalypse (sometimes referred to as “that site with all those old toy robot ads.” So with some help (because he’s not yet been sucked into the vortex that is the iTunes store) I finally upload all 25 (to date) podcasticas.

Today was podcast one through three.

I’ve already threatened Steve with running commentaries with respect to select (possible all) podcasts, and I was in the middle of putting a second one up on his site, when it dawned on me. Hey, I have a website too (hello beautiful fairplaythings!) And since the unexpected and unexplained hiatus that is the ongoing collectible of the day, why not put my comments on my site and make Steve come to me. Sounded good in my head anyway.

For those who want to hear the podcast to understand what I am talking about, where Steve ponders the success and failings of the Shogun Warriors, it’s episode two here.

I always get a little indignant when people talk about the wonder of Japanese engineering being key to the success of the Transformers, because the toy line is really the bastard child of east and west. Takara tried to market diaclone toys in North America to limited success, but it was the genius of mother Hasbro that created the characters (and allegiance) that led to thousands of young robotronians uprising in their suburban homes and demanding they get their Megatron and their Optimus Prime too!

I was thinking about this in terms of Steve’s comments about Shogun Warriors, particularly with respect to Godzilla. The commercial for the thunder lizard implies that Mattel did envision him as a possible villain, even if they were not prepared to create a symbol for his chest. Really, if Hasbro did anything, it was give us the battle of good versus evil, and much better names than Mazinger, Combattler, and Daigan. And I wonder too if the Shogun would have been even more popular if someone had done tech specs for the guys.

Certainly the line could have been helped in the imagination of children with a cartoon. And for us children of the eighties, wasn’t there a cartoon for everything? I mean Robotixeven had one, a construction toy where you would think heroes and villains wouldn’t apply. And yet the original toy packaging came to reflect the battles of the Protectons and Terrakors.

But the seventies was a different place and a different time. Where there were laws against directly marketing to children in the form of 22 minute advertisements with mini-advertisements embedded in the programming. Steve talks about the links between popular toys and movies (and live action television), and my understanding is that the use of such likenesses as Buck Rogers, Star Wars, and the Six Million Dollar Man was fair game because their target audience wasn’t completely intended to be 7-12 years old. (Clearly it was a time before grown men outnumbered children in the toy isles of a Toys ‘r Us.) Certainly, comic books (Micronauts, GIJoe, even ROM) were seen as key marketing methods to encourage the success of a toy line because the door to cartoons was closed.

So I would maintain that Mattel couldn’t go down the path of having a cartoon directly. The company probably benefitted from the existence of Godzilla as a cartoon, but there were probably enough differences that their legal team could explain there was insufficient links (and this may explain why the toy Godzilla looked so different than what was expected, even given the technology of the day). I would imagine that the introduction of Force Fiveat the end of the Shogun Warrior line was not coincidental, and may even have hurried the toyline off the shelves if Mattel had been leaning on getting out of the toyline anyway.

In any event, while I’m not sure if Ronald Reagen deserves an airport named in his honour, let it be said there should be at least three cartoon studios rechristened in his name.

Coming back to the end of the line for Shogun Warriors, a four year toy run may seem insignificant, but we are spoiled by the popularity of so many “branding” holdovers from the 1980s. There are not a lot of unified toy lines that last four years. I agree with wikipedia’s hypothesis that the end of the toy line came about because of declining demand meeting improved safety concerns, although I expect other factors were involved as well. I’m sure the issue of licensing came up, and Mattel may have looked at the extra cost for safety changes and the declining sales numbers for the line, and decided it wasn’t worth it to continue to pursue the licensing agreement.

Anyway, just a few thoughts on a great podcast. I’m encouraged to hear about the toys of my youth, properties I think need a little love. And now I need to get back to the collectible of the day. Stay tuned!

***

I would be remiss if I didn’t add a comment here about the passing of Michael Gough. It’s sad to see him go. He will always be Alfred to me.

5 Comments »

  1. Hey Colin,

    Glad to see you posting so regularly again. We meet back Botcon ‘09 (gave you some TF stickers outside the dealer room). Love seeing your custom munnies any chance I get.

    My wife and I do a podcast about Transformers, G.I. Joe, Master of the Universe and Star Wars over at OpenYourToys.com. We’re also on iTunes. We’re definitely not as poetic as Macrocranios, but we have fun. We just recorded our 50th episode and it’s actually all about us. Kind of a get to know us episode. We listed all of our favorite podcasts at some point. Probably take a listen to episode 49 first to see if you like what you hear, then listen to 50 for more about us.

    Can’t wait for more post and maybe we’ll see you and your munnies at Botcon ‘11.

    Peace…Jason

    Comment by Slick McFavorite — March 20, 2011 @ 7:35 pm

  2. I am sorry I haven’t got back to you on this! It’s exactly the type of conversation I wished to elicit from listeners back when I recorded that episode and had all the time in the world to respond to people. But I’m just so swamped right now by schoolwork that I have zero time to knock out a couple well thought out paragraphs about the finer points of the marketing strategies of sci-fi action figure lines like Shogun Warriors in the late seventies. I will get back to you on this, though! Thanks of course for listening to all that me talking to myself. I’m looking forward to rocket punching some holes in at least a couple of the points you made!

    Comment by Steve — March 20, 2011 @ 8:58 pm

  3. I have to get across my respect for your kind-heartedness for folks that really need help with this particular subject. Your personal dedication to passing the message along has been especially interesting and has surely helped some individuals just like me to achieve their dreams. Your warm and friendly publication signifies a lot a person like me and still more to my peers. Thanks a lot; from all of us.

    Comment by nike sb — November 19, 2023 @ 12:46 am

  4. I have to convey my passion for your kind-heartedness in support of folks that need assistance with that idea. Your personal commitment to getting the message all-around had been wonderfully interesting and has always empowered guys and women much like me to arrive at their endeavors. Your new interesting facts denotes much a person like me and extremely more to my peers. Many thanks; from each one of us.

    Comment by off white clothing — December 4, 2023 @ 7:57 pm

  5. My spouse and i felt very fulfilled that Raymond could round up his analysis through your ideas he acquired through your web pages. It’s not at all simplistic to simply be making a gift of key points which some other people have been selling. And now we realize we’ve got you to be grateful to for that. The explanations you’ve made, the straightforward website navigation, the relationships your site aid to instill - it’s got everything astonishing, and it’s letting our son in addition to the family recognize that this subject is exciting, which is incredibly fundamental. Thanks for all the pieces!

    Comment by off white clothing — December 22, 2023 @ 11:09 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress